Edinburgh

Reviews Edinburgh Desserts

Mary's Milk Bar, Grassmarket
Mary's Milk Bar, Grassmarket

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Gelato and chocolate shop in Grassmarket, Edinburgh

Mary's Milk Bar

Gelato Under the Castle

4 of 5

A tiny shop in the Grassmarket, a window full of Edinburgh Castle, and a woman who comes in early to make that day's gelato and chocolate by hand. That is the whole of Mary's Milk Bar, and it is enough. Mary worked as a chocolatier before she trained at the Carpigiani Gelato University in Bologna, which is the kind of credential you want behind a counter like this. The flavours change daily, sometimes within the same day, and the good ones sell out. Instagram tells you what is on.

Order the Spaghetti Sundae once, for the theatre. A scoop of the day's flavour, a pile of milk ice cream pushed through into spaghetti, amarena cherry meatballs, toasted honey breadcrumbs, white chocolate parmesan with black pepper, and a pinch of rosemary salt. It is a dessert that makes a joke and then backs it up. On a cold day, and Edinburgh has a few hundred of those, get a hot chocolate float: your choice of gelato dropped into hot chocolate.

The stools and bar are made from recycled milk bottles. The locals take their cones to Granny's Green Steps and eat in front of the castle. The summer queue is real, so go early or go in winter, when the shop is quiet and keeps shorter hours. A gelato brick to take home buys you about an hour before it needs a freezer.

Order this
Whatever flavours Mary made that morning, The Spaghetti Sundae, A hot chocolate float in cold weather, A bar of her chocolate to take home
The damage
$
Go
Winter afternoons, Wednesday to Sunday, when the queue vanishes; in summer go between 11am and 2pm
Find it
19 Grassmarket, Edinburgh EH1 2HS