Edinburgh

Reviews Edinburgh Wine Bars

Smith & Gertrude, Stockbridge
Smith & Gertrude, Stockbridge

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Wine and cheese bar, flights and by the glass in Stockbridge, Edinburgh

Smith & Gertrude

Cheese, Wine and a Turntable

3.5 of 5

Smith & Gertrude opened in 2015 on Hamilton Place in Stockbridge with a philosophy short enough to print on a coaster. Wine, cheese, company. That is the whole pitch, and it is a good one. The room is more bar than pub, built for a glass and a board rather than a long session, and there are records waiting their turn on the turntable.

The trick is the flights. Each one sets three wines beside three cheeses, and the team builds them around wines that, in their own words, come from the wrong side of the tracks. One recent flight walked through Palomino, from a still white out of Cádiz to an amontillado from Jerez, each glass with a cheese chosen to argue with it. Another showed off an urban winery in Lyon. The by-the-glass list is refreshed daily, and the English sparkling section, with bottles from Surrey and Dorset, should cure anyone who still thinks English fizz is a joke.

Food stays on theme. Boards of three or five cheeses, charcuterie from Scotland and the continent, Company Bakery bread, and grilled sourdough sandwiches built on Montgomery cheddar or on Gorgonzola and Taleggio together. Baked Camembert shows up when the weather turns. Stockbridge opens at four on weekdays, stays shut on Tuesdays, and starts at one on weekends. There is a second branch on Portobello High Street for anyone heading to the beach.

Order this
A cheese and wine flight, Whatever is new on the daily by-the-glass list, An English sparkling from Surrey or Dorset, The Montgomery cheddar grilled sourdough sandwich, Baked Camembert in autumn and winter
The damage
$$
Go
Weekday evenings from 16.00 (closed Tuesdays) or weekend afternoons from 13.00
Find it
26 Hamilton Place, Edinburgh EH3 5AU