Montreal

Reviews Montreal Dinner

Pizzeria Magpie, Mile End
Magpie, Mile End

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Pizzeria in Mile End, Montreal

Pizzeria Magpie

The Neighbourhood Oven on Maguire

3.5 of 5

A wood oven, a family running it, and a short street in Mile End. That is Magpie, on Rue Maguire since 2010, with no interest in becoming a concept. In Mile End, where a bakery can turn into a lifestyle brand overnight, that restraint deserves a medal. It calls itself a neighbourhood pizzeria. It means it.

The dough leans Neapolitan, the toppings lean Montreal, and the menu stays short enough to read before the server comes back. Start with the Magpie Margherita and pay the extra to swap the bocconcini for a whole burrata, because life is short. The Amandine is the one to argue about: ricotta, gruyère and mozzarella under roasted salted almonds and spicy honey, a pizza that tastes like a dare that paid off. The Viande Fumée puts Felix Mish smoked meat on a pie with Dijon aioli, cheddar and dill, which is the most Montreal sentence a pizza has ever spoken. For the table, get the meatballs made with meat from Boucherie Chez Vito, and a beet salad so somebody can say they ate a vegetable.

The drinks are local and sensible: Wills Pils, a Caesar, a short wine list. Book for groups of eight or more by phone. Come at lunch midweek, sit near the oven, and let the place be exactly what it says it is.

Order this
Magpie Margherita with a whole burrata, Amandine with roasted almonds and spicy honey, Viande Fumée with Felix Mish smoked meat, Meatballs with Chez Vito beef
The damage
$$
Go
Weekday lunch, Tuesday to Friday, or an early dinner; closed Mondays
Find it
16 Rue Maguire, Montréal, QC H2T 1B8