New York City

Reviews New York City Bars

Bemelmans Bar, Upper East Side
Bemelmans Bar, The Carlyle

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Hotel piano bar in Upper East Side, New York City

Bemelmans Bar

Madeline Never Left

3.5 of 5

Ludwig Bemelmans wrote the Madeline books and, in the 1940s, painted the walls of a hotel bar in exchange for a year and a half of free rooms for his family. The deal looks smarter every year. The bar opened in 1947 at the Carlyle, and the Art Deco room still glows in rose gold, brass and maroon, with a gold leaf ceiling and the murals of Central Park running along the walls.

The mural shows Madeline and her classmates across the four seasons, with ice-skating elephants and rabbits smoking cigars, which is the best argument ever made for the Upper East Side. The most requested drink is a dirty martini, and the bartenders reportedly make about a thousand a night. Dale DeGroff revamped the cocktail program in 2001. The Gillespie and the JFK Daiquiri keep the older story going.

A piano plays most nights, which has earned the room a reputation as one of the city's best places for live piano. Prices are high, so keep your expectations calibrated, but so is the quality of the room. Wear a jacket, go early, and sit near the murals. Expect a crowd at peak hours, and plan for a wait. The reward is a room that has kept its charm for decades and still seems to enjoy having you in it.

Order this
A very dirty martini, The Gillespie, The JFK Daiquiri, A table near the mural
The damage
$$$$
Go
Early evening, midweek, in a jacket
Find it
35 E 76th St (The Carlyle), New York, NY 10021
Instagram
@bemelmansbar