New York City

Reviews New York City Dinner

Gage & Tollner, Downtown Brooklyn
Gage & Tollner, Downtown Brooklyn

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Oyster and chop house in Downtown Brooklyn, New York City

Gage & Tollner

Back From the Dead on Fulton Street

3.5 of 5

Gage & Tollner fed Brooklyn from 1879 until 2004. Then the lights went dark for a long time. A comeback was planned for 2020, the pandemic took that year apart, and the doors finally reopened on April 15, 2021. Landmarks in this town rarely get a second life without turning into museums.

The restaurant calls itself an oyster and chop house for the 21st century, with top-quality ingredients simply and perfectly prepared. That is a good brief, and it is not a lie. So start with oysters, then move to a chop, and let the plain-spoken cooking do the talking. Upstairs sits Sunken Harbor Club, a small bar with tropical cocktails and small plates, which is a good place to land if the main room is full or you have too much dinner in you to go home yet.

Hours are generous. Gage & Tollner opens at five on weekdays and eleven on weekends, with the bar upstairs staying late on Friday and Saturday. Reservations are on the website. This is a place for celebrations, first dates and visiting relatives who want a Brooklyn that feels old. The room has history. The kitchen has a point to prove, and it keeps proving it. I would send anyone there with a few hours and a thirst.

Order this
Oysters, A chop, A tropical cocktail upstairs at Sunken Harbor Club
The damage
$$$
Go
Weekend lunch, or a weeknight after five, then upstairs for a drink
Find it
372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201