New York City

Reviews New York City Dinner

The Grill, Midtown East
The Grill, Midtown East

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Steakhouse in Midtown East, New York City

The Grill

Dinner as a Floor Show

3.5 of 5

Put on a jacket. The Grill sits in the Seagram Building, in the room where The Four Seasons used to operate, and it opened in 2017 into a space that already weighed a ton. The dark wood is lit like a stage, the ceilings are tall, and the staff move as if the whole evening was rehearsed. It was.

Dinner here is a floor show with butter. The prime rib comes on a trolley, at $95. The pasta à la presse is made with an antique press from 1901, which is either a pasta course or a museum piece, and both are true. A crab Louis with avocado gets finished at the table. The Seagram crab cake is reportedly ninety-nine percent crab with a crisp potato crown. Dessert is a Baked Alaska that arrives flaming. There are eight martinis on offer, and the server pours them from sixteen inches up into a goblet the size of a small bucket. I respect the commitment.

It is expensive, and I will not pretend otherwise. This is for the promotion, the anniversary, the client who needs convincing. Reservations are reasonable to get, unlike at some of its flashier cousins, and it is open six nights a week. Order the trolley, order the martini, and let the whole production wash over you. Midtown East rarely does romance, but when it tries, it tries in a tuxedo.

Order this
The prime rib trolley, Pasta à la presse, Avocado crab Louis, made at the table, Baked Alaska, set alight at the table, A martini, poured from a great height
The damage
$$$$
Go
A weeknight, jacket on, when you want an occasion
Find it
99 E 52nd St, New York, NY 10022