
Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.
Restaurant in Deer Park / Avenue Road hill, Toronto
Scaramouche
Coconut Cream Pie on the Hill
Every city keeps a restaurant that its parents took it to. In Toronto, for a lot of people, that is Scaramouche. It sits at One Benvenuto Place, tucked into a building on the hill above Avenue Road, with complimentary valet out front and the downtown skyline laid out in the windows. It is old-school the way a well-made coat is old-school. It fits, it lasts, and nobody needs to explain it.
The menu reads like a contract both parties have honoured for years. Québec duck, halibut, rack of lamb and filet mignon, with mains running roughly forty-five to seventy dollars, alongside pastas like a Sicilian-style lamb ragu and shellfish pappardelle. None of it is trying to start a revolution. It is trying to be cooked properly and served by people who know what they are doing, which is rarer than it ought to be.
Then there is the pie. The coconut cream pie, coconut custard under chantilly cream with white chocolate shavings and dark chocolate sauce, is the dish people mention before they mention the restaurant. It is loved enough that they sell whole pies for takeout, Tuesday to Saturday, in a half-hour window just after five. I have eaten street food on four continents and I am still not too proud to line up for a pie. Book a weeknight, ask for a window, and save room. That is not advice. That is the plan.
- Order this
- Coconut cream pie, Québec duck, Rack of lamb, Shellfish pappardelle
- The damage
- $$$$
- Go
- A weeknight dinner by the window
- Find it
- 1 Benvenuto Pl, Toronto, ON M4V 2L1
- Website
- scaramoucherestaurant.com
